Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Silksong's 'Very Positive' Launch Reveals a Fissure in Hollow Knight Fandom
#1
The wait is over, but the verdict is not unanimous. After more than six years of anticipation, Hollow Knight: Silksong finally arrived and immediately became a cultural event: it was the most wishlisted game on Steam, storefronts buckled under demand, and the game reached a peak concurrent player count of roughly half a million. Yet the first wave of Steam user reviews tells a more complicated story. Silksong currently sits at a 'Very Positive' rating, with 94% of roughly 27,000 user ratings positive—just short of the 95% threshold needed for 'Overwhelmingly Positive.' For most games, that would be a triumph. For a sequel to Hollow Knight, a title with 97% positive ratings from more than 140,000 reviews, it is a signal that something has shifted. Is 'Very Positive' really a disappointment, or does it simply prove how impossible the expectations had become?

[Image: 6ae3e08ca7a0d0034f9c113fimdmZFWW07]

A Sequel Measured Against a Masterpiece

The numbers are close, and that is precisely the problem. Initial Metacritic user scores placed Silksong at 8.9, compared with Hollow Knight's 9.1. On Steam, the gap between 94% and 97% positive may look small, but for a highly anticipated sequel, anything shy of greatness can feel underwhelming. Many negative reviews begin with the same wistful sentence: 'I really wanted to love this game.' Steam user Icarus IX put the mood bluntly: 'Hollow Knight is a masterpiece. Silksong is not.'

Can any sequel escape the shadow of a predecessor that fans have spent years treating as untouchable? That question hangs over much of the early criticism. The disappointment is not that Silksong is bad, but that it is not the same kind of revelation. Fans who expected another flawless evolution of Hollow Knight's design have instead found a game that asks them to accept new rules, sharper penalties, and a different rhythm.

Metric
Silksong
Hollow Knight

Steam user rating
94% positive
97% positive

Steam ratings
~27,000
140,000+

Metacritic user score
8.9
9.1

Peak concurrent players
~500,000
—

Combat, Currency, and the Feeling of Fighting the Game

The most common complaint is combat. Hornet is noticeably squishier than the Hollow Knight, and many enemies deal two masks of damage even as she becomes more powerful. According to critics, that combination makes battles feel frustrating rather than fun. The Rosary currency system has also drawn fire. These small red beads are used for everything from unlocking skills and maps to creating rest areas, but not every enemy drops them. That scarcity can stall upgrades and slow progression. Then there is the broader design critique: some players call the game unnecessarily punishing and argue it is not optimized for Hornet's abilities. Is Silksong asking players to master a new rhythm, or is it simply fighting them? The negative reviews lean toward the latter.

[Image: 6afe3e83bf7950450975f2d481SYLGIP07]

The comparison to Hollow Knight is unavoidable. As Icarus IX explained, Hollow Knight had 'the slickest, tightest game design ever,' and players felt frustrated at their own mistakes rather than at the game itself. Silksong, in contrast, feels to some like they are fighting against the game rather than growing with it. That distinction matters. A sequel can be harder, stranger, and more ambitious, but if players believe the difficulty comes from design rather than challenge, goodwill erodes.

Translation Troubles and Team Cherry's Response

Another flashpoint has little to do with combat: the Chinese translation. The poor quality of the localization prompted Team Cherry's Matthew Griffin to issue a public update saying it would be improved 'over the coming weeks.' For a global launch of this scale, localization is not a footnote. Can a rough translation sour first impressions enough to affect a game's reputation? For some players, it clearly did. The fact that Team Cherry responded quickly shows the studio is listening, but it also highlights how many moving parts surround a launch of this size.

[Image: 6adfec031875246fb2db0a7elBbZbqEi07]

The Broader Picture

The positive reviews still far outweigh the negative ones, and the percentages may change as more players finish the game. The excitement remains enormous, and a peak of half a million concurrent players is not the profile of a failed launch. But the early reception is a case study in expectation. Hollow Knight captivated fans with tight level and combat design; Silksong's harsher combat and stingier economy feel to some like a departure. In 2026, the conversation around Silksong is less about whether it is good and more about what kind of good it is.

Very Positive is not a disaster. It is a warning that six years of waiting created a standard no game could fully meet. The question now is whether Team Cherry's post-launch support—starting with localization fixes—can close the gap. Can Silksong eventually earn the 'Overwhelmingly Positive' label, or will it remain a brilliant but divisive follow-up? For now, the answer is written in red beads, two-mask hits, and thousands of reviews that begin with the same wistful sentence: 'I really wanted to love this game.'

For players still on the fence—or those waiting to see how the localization and balance updates land—the cost of entry can be as decisive as the review score. Rather than committing at full price, it helps to see how Silksong and similar titles are priced across storefronts; DealNest offers a straightforward way to compare prices here before you decide whether the wait was worth it.
Reply


Messages In This Thread
Silksong's 'Very Positive' Launch Reveals a Fissure in Hollow Knight Fandom - by xtameembb - 1 hour ago

Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)